Tomasino's New York Pizzeria - Lake Mary, FLTomasino's New York Pizzeria   407-898-7499

Print Menu

Appetizers

“Bossman’s Meatball Sliders” 

6.99
(3) delicious Garlic Knots stuffed with meatball marinara, ricotta and mozzarella cheese. Brushed with our homemade garlic butter and topped with our Parmesan & Romano blend of cheese

“The Big Shot” 

6.99
An enormous, delicious homemade meatball packed with flavor, topped with marinara sauce & fresh ricotta cheese, sprinkled with basil

“The Leaning Tower of Caprese” 

8.99
Thick sliced tomatoes, mozzarella & roasted peppers stacked into a leaning tower of amore. Served with house dressing & topped with fresh basil

Bruschetta 

7.99
A delicious chopped array of juicy red tomatoes mixed in with shredded feta along with our house balsamic dressing topped with fresh basil and Parmigiana and Romano cheese. Served on top of freshly baked garlic bread squares

Buratta, Buratta 

10.99
Bottom layer starts off with delicious garlic toast, then we add a thick cut beefsteak tomato slab, and here is the best part... a whopping 4oz. pesto infused Buratta Ball we make in house. Topped off with tour amazing hick cut maple bacon!

Fried Mozzarella 

6.99
Whole milk mozzarella rolled in our seasoned bread crumbs and deep fried to golden brown & served w marinara sauce

Garlicky Cheese Knots & Marinara 

3.99
Fresh baked garlic knots, brushed with our homemade butter garlic, sprinkled with Romano cheese and with a slab of milk white Mozzarella cheese. Guaranteed for a stringy cheesy delicious starter

Patsy’s Parmesan Pesto Fries 

4.99
We fry them, dust them with fresh parmigiana & parsley and top it w pesto drizzle. Served with lemon wedge. Simple but delish

The Bosslady’s Flatbread 

9.99
Happy wife, happy life..right? She came up with this great recipe, said I had to add it to our menu! Our house made dough, baked to perfection with sliced roma tomatoes, pesto drizzled, all topped with fresh mozzarella and finished w light basil, parmigiana sprinkle and of course.. balsamic reduction to seal the deal!

Buffalo Wings

10 Pieces 

10.99

20 Pieces 

19.99

Salads

Bella Gianna Arugula Salad 

9.99
We start off with a Chicken cutlet pan fried. Then we add a bed of fresh arugula, shaved parmigiana and chopped tomatoes all on top tossed w our special recipe olive oil. Served with a lemon. Use it

Caesar Salad 

7.49
Romaine lettuce & shaved parmigiana Reggiano cheese with croutons

Fully Loaded Combo Salad 

8.99
This is the boss of salads.. all our regular veggies are there but we also bring the meats and cheeses to the sit down... including fresh mozzarella, ham , salami , feta cheese, sliced mozzarella , marinated roasted peppers, topped with an peperoncini pepper & Kalamata olives

Greek 

7.99
Kalamata olives, ham, salami, provolone, feta cheese & pepperoncinis

I Did It My Way  

12.99
In honor of old blue eyes, we are doing this salad OUR way. Romaine & arugula is the base then we add tomatoes, cucumbers, caramelized onions, roasted peppers, grilled chicken, boiled eggs and maple wood thick cut bacon and lastly, a lovely cloud of goat cheese, and that’s a wrap!

Tomasino’s Spinach Salad 

9.99
Delicious leafy spinach, chopped tomatoes, grilled chicken & crumbled bacon, topped with feta & dressing of your choice

Sides

Fries 

3.49

Garlic Bread 

2.99

Garlic Bread with Cheese 

3.99

Side Caesar 

3.49
Romaine lettuce & shaved parmigiana Reggiano cheese with croutons

Side of Alfredo or Tomasinos Sauce 

2.99

Side of Meat Sauce 

2.99

Side of Meatballs (2) 

3.99

Side Salad 

3.49
Lettuce, chopped tomatoes, onions,cucumbers, green peppers, carrots and cabbage

Subs

Cheesesteak 

8.99
Thin sliced ribeye perfectly seasoned with grilled onions, peppers, and mushrooms, tossed in our secret sauce then layered with mozzarella and placed in a crusty sub roll, toasted to a perfect masterpiece

Chicken Parmigiana 

8.99
Our hand pounded and breaded chicken breast topped with our homemade marinara sauce, baked with mozzarella and toasted to perfection

Eggplant Parmigiana 

7.99
Traditional thin sliced eggplant, hand breaded, sizzled golden brown then topped with our homemade marinara sauce, baked with mozzarella and toasted to perfection

Italian Combo (hot/cold) 

7.99
Premium meats Ham, salami, pepperoni and our signature mozzarella cheese loaded into our crusty sub roll, topped with lettuce, tomato, and pepperoncini served with our delicious house dressing on the side

Meatball Parmigiana 

7.99
Our famous meatballs stuffed inside of a loaf of our crusty sub roll, topped with our homemade marinara sauce, baked with mozzarella and toasted to perfection

NY Deli Chicken Classic 

9.99
Chicken cutlet, romaine lettuce, sliced tomatoes & fresh Mozzarella all on a garlic butter toasted bun. Add balsamic drizzle for $1.59

Gourmet Pizza

Arthur Ave Style Pizza 

Because we are Bronx natives and we have one of oldest little Italy districts in NYC... we like to think we know a thing or two about Salame .. the one on this pie is a spicy salame AKA (peppered Italian salami) we top it with caramelized onions and goat cheese. Finished with drizzle of our spicy marinade just to make you look like the boss that you are! A sprinkle of red crushed pepper never hurt anyone.

14 inch

 $18.99

18 inch

 $24.99

“Green with Envy” AKA Pesto Pizza 

Our house recipe Pesto topped with our fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil and baked to perfection

14 inch

 $16.49

18 inch

 $20.49

“Joe the Distributor” AKA Meatball Parmigiana 

Meatballs, topped with mozzarella, drizzled with red San Marzano tomato sauce, ricotta cheese and sprinkled with basil

14 inch

 $18.49

18 inch

 $23.49

“Ricotta Be Kidding Me” AKA Bianca Pizza 

Mozzarella, ricotta, parmigiana & fresh garlic. if this pizza has no red sauce.. It better be good! We up the anty.. Lots of garlic , parmesan and ricotta all atop of beautiful layer of milky white mozzarella

14 inch

 $16.49

18 inch

 $20.49

“The Butcher’s Pie” 

Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, bacon & ham. All of our meats are seasoned and cooked on premises .. Enjoy this delicious combo of meats and cheese.

14 inch

 $20.49

18 inch

 $25.49

“The Gardener” 

Onions, green peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes & black olives. We receive and hand cut our fresh produce that is locally grown daily! Warning: you will feel healthy and happy after eating this pizza!

14 inch

 $18.49

18 inch

 $23.49

“The Mechanic” 

Pepperoni, sausage, green pepper, onions, mushrooms, black olives & extra cheese. This is your deluxe, best of both meat and veggie world combines for a superpower pizza that can fix it all!

14 inch

 $19.49

18 inch

 $25.49

“Tomasinos Almost Famous Arugula Pie” 

First we cook the pie, no sauce-just cheese, then we toss our special ingredients: arugula, chicken cutlet, chopped tomatoes, shaved parmigiana, garlic, oregano, seasoned olive oil. Then we spread all this deliciousness over the pizza and add freshly squeezed lemon

14 inch

 $21.49

18 inch

 $26.49

Cheese Pizza 

14 inch

 $13.99

18 inch

 $17.99

Chicken Mediterranean 

Tomatoes, onions, green peppers, Kalamata olives, grilled chicken, feta cheese, spinach, mushrooms & fresh garlic. A melting pot of freshness.. The feta paired with the kalamata olives really make this pizza a top choice!

14 inch

 $21.49

18 inch

 $27.99

Don Tomasino 

Bianca topped with our special recipe, breaded eggplant with spinach & tomatoes drizzle with our special pink sauce. If Pizzas had a boss, it would be this pie

14 inch

 $20.49

18 inch

 $27.49

Gluten Free 

12 inch

 $13.99

Gourmet Toppings 

14in $2.99ea & 18in $4.50ea: • Chicken Cutlet • Grilled Chicken • Fresh Whole Milk Mozzarella • Kalamata Olives • Steak

Joncarlo’s Exclusive VIP Pizza 

Stuffed with ham, Genoa salami, provolone, pepperoni, sausage & meatballs, served with marinara sauce

14 inch

 $29.99

18 inch

 $34.99

Mamas Moo-za-rellll Pie 

This is the way us New Yorkers grew up on Brooklyn pizza. First you apply the Delicious imported special blend Moozarell to the dough. Then proceed to drizzle the pizza sauce on top of the moozarell. Last thing, sprinkle the Romano & parmigiana cheese on top and BAM! A Pizza our Mama would be proud to serve!

14 inch

 $18.49

18 inch

 $23.49

Margherita 

Our homemade dough brushed with our special house infused olive oil, Roma tomatoes, fresh sliced mozzarella, fresh basil, sprinkled to perfection with freshly grated parmigiana cheese. With Balsamic Reduction add $2.00 for 14 inch and $4.00 for 18 inch

14 inch

 $16.49

18 inch

 $20.49

Seriously Delicious Spinach Pie 

Ok here goes nothing, Bianca pizza we add Roma slices tomatoes and our house recipe (only the boss got the recipes) Creamy Spinach! Baked to perfection

14 inch

 $18.49

18 inch

 $23.49

The Big Cheese 

Picture this: A loving matrimony of beef and cheese loyalty... Since you are family, we toss the bacon on their as a favor. We could just call it the Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza, but that would be too simple for this boss of a pie!

14 inch

 $18.99

18 inch

 $24.99

The JUST WOW Pie 

The house specialty pink sauce is the base, creamy Buratta cheese sprinkled on top with fresh basil leaves for "just Wow" flavor!

14 inch

 $18.99

18 inch

 $24.99

Toppings 

14in $1.99ea & 18in $2.50ea: • Anchovies • Crumbled Bacon • Black Olives • Extra Cheese • Eggplant • Feta • Chopped Garlic • Chopped Green Peppers • Sliced Ham • Jalapeños • Meatballs • Fresh Mushrooms • Chopped Onions • Pepperoni • Pepperoncinis • Pineapple • Roasted Red Peppers • Salami • Seasoned Mild Sausage • Deliciously Sautéed Spinach • Sliced Tomatoes

Vegan Pizza 

All vegan ingredients down to the dough. We found a way, to even make this one taste delicious!!

14 inch

 $17.99

18 inch

 $24.99

Calzones

Cheese Calzone 

8.99
Additional fillings $1.50 each

Special Calzone 

10.99
Ricotta, pepperoni, onion, sausage, mushrooms, green pepper & mozzarella. Baked To Perfection!

The Butcher’s 

10.99
Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, bacon & ham

The Gardener 

10.99
Onions, green pepper, mushrooms, tomatoes & black olives

Pasta

Mama’s Mac & Cheese 

11.99
Creamy old fashioned cheesy penne pasta topped with panko bread crumbs. Add grilled or chicken cutlet $4.00

Pasta Bolognese 

13.99
Our meat sauce tossed with pasta & topped with fresh Mozzarella cheese

Pasta Marinara 

10.99

Pasta Vivianna 

14.99
Our take on a typical village family style pasta... combines flavors of fresh bacon, garlicky onions and grilled chicken, seared together and tossed in a Parmesan creamy Alfredo sauce topped with a grilled lemon and if our Vivi loves it, so will you

Pasta with Meatballs 

13.99
Our traditional pasta dish. Your choice of pasta with our delicious meatballs

Penne Alfredo 

12.99
Our house creamy Alfredo sauce tossed with penne pasta & topped with fresh parmigiana cheese

Baked Specialties

Baked Cheese Ravioli 

10.99
Our pasta packed filled with a romano/ricotta mixture, tossed in marinara and topped with mozzarella

Baked Ziti 

11.99
Our penne pasta with a mixture of ricotta, mozzarella & romano with marinara, baked in the oven like Nana makes it!

Chicken Parmigiana 

13.99
Our deliciously hand breaded chicken cutlet served on top of heap of pasta marinara, topped with our whole milk mozzarella, baked to perfection

Chicken Tomasino 

14.99
Our chicken cutlet with a pasta of your choice, tossed in our special pink Tomasino sauce, finished with our fresh whole milk mozzarella, baked to perfection and topped with parmigiana Reggiano & fresh basil

Eggplant Parmigiana 

12.99
Our deliciously hand breaded eggplant served on top of heap of pasta marinara topped with our whole milk mozzarella, baked to perfection

Desserts

Cannoli 

2.99
Fried tube shape pastry dough filled with a sweet creamy filing of ricotta cheese, chocolate chips, sugar & vanilla

Junior’s N.Y. Cheesecake 

6.99
Imported from Brooklyn, N.Y. for the purist. Junior’s FAMOUS N.Y. style... What all N.Y.-style cheesecake aspire to be. Rated “Best Overall” by the Wall Street Journal. With strawberry $7.99

Mini Cannoli 

Dozen

 $16.99

Half Dozen

 $8.99

Tiramisu 

5.50
The most Heavenly Italian dessert. Lady fingers, marscapone cheese and espresso coffee

Tomasino’s Ultimate Chocolate Mousse 

5.99
For all you chocolate lovers. This is the rich creamy chocolate you love

Drinks

Beer 

Featuring Peroni and Yuengling Beer on Draft. Coors Light and Sam Adams. Seasonal beers

Bottled Water 

Pepsi Products